State of Independents

opinions free from chains

World Book Night – Am I alone? Not so much…

In the last few weeks, I’ve been told quite often that I’m wrong to be worried about World Book Night and the giving away of £9 million of stock.  I’ve been told that it doesn’t further devalue the book as a purchase; that it doesn’t reinforce the notion that authors should work for free; that [...]

World Book Night – misguided and misjudged?

As you know (or may not – it’s amazing the number of people who haven’t heard of this most trumpeted event), 5th March has been declared World Book Night, emanating from an idea put forward by Jamie Byng of Canongate.  Even the title is hubristic – there is nothing global about the project.  20,000 ‘givers’ [...]

Don’t let books be marginalised – save Bookstart

I could write a great deal here about the need to encourage in children the habit of reading for pleasure and the need to help parents to start reading with their children.  There is masses to say about the folly of government plans to remove funding from the brilliant Bookstart scheme which has since 1992 [...]

An Education

[Advance warning: rant ahead...]
Since early February I have been organising the Scottish book launch for a new title by an award-winning and very popular author who writes books for teenagers. It’s going to be a schools event and when the publisher phoned us up to talk about it we were extremely excited. We were asked [...]

Self Published Authors – before you send me your book bear this in mind…

Ask any bookseller about self-published books and they will groan.  Depending on how many self-published books they are asked to stock they will groan and bang their heads on the table.  If they are given as many as we are they will groan, bang their heads on the table and demand a stiff drink.
It’s not [...]

Gatekeepers of Last Resort

I read this post on Jane Smith’s excellent blog a few days ago about the roles of literary agents as gatekeepers to the publishing industry and also as a primary filter to ensure that what is submitted to publishers is actually the genre they’re interested in, that it’s of an appropriate standard, that it’s saleable* [...]

Classy, really classy, Waterstone’s

This morning, savouring our Christmas break but still committed workaholics, Andrew and I met at Brown’s on George Street to spend a very pleasant hour or two over tea and toast making plans for bookshop events and choosing titles for our Book of the Week and Book of the Month promotions (the only titles we [...]

About Us

Welcome to State of Independents. I'm Vanessa Robertson. I live in Edinburgh and my husband and I own a bookshop and tiny publishing house. This is where I write about the book trade as I see it and I'm not always as diplomatic as I should be... We write about what's going on in our businesses over at The Fidra Blog

What we do

Who we are

  • Links